AskMuallim

ISSUE IN TIRMIDHI

View previous topic View next topic Go down

ISSUE IN TIRMIDHI

Post  Abrar on Tue Nov 23, 2010 3:06 pm

In the book of Tirmidhi,chapter of [ma ja aa fe fadhl let tahur],from [wa fil baab] where Imam Tirmidhi states who else has narrated the hadeeth he mentions the name of [ as sunaabih].
The question I would like to pose to my respected brothers is who does Imam Tirmidhi refer to as [As Sunaabih]?
[Abrar Mehmood]

Abrar

Posts : 10
Join date : 2010-11-09

Back to top Go down

Answer to Who is As Sunaabih?

Post  Abrar on Sun Nov 28, 2010 9:29 pm

1- Abdullah as Sunaabihi { He is a Sahaabi}
2- Abdur rehman bin ghusaila abu abdillah as sunaabihi { He is a tabiee}
3- As Sunaabih bin al a'mar al ahmasee { He is Sahaabi}

Now lets find out what the respective scholars have to state on who AS SUNAABIH is?

1. Imam Malik has included the first name in one of his narrations to the prophet.
2. Imam Bukhari states that Imam Malik has made a mistake in this issue and further states that the first one does not exist at all.
3. Imam Bukhari,Imam Tirmidhi and others agree that there is only 2 of them,the 2nd and the 3rd one.
4. Sheikh Ahmad Shakir has written a book " AT TAREEQATUL WAADIHA FE TUNBEENUS SUNAABIHA" , in which he agrees with the opinion of Imam Malik.
5. Saad bin Laythee also agrees with Imam Malik.

In conclusion the most popular view is that of Imam Bukhari and Imam Tirmidhi.
{Reference used is Sheikh Mohammed Akram Nadvi's sharh on Tirmidhi which is not in book form at the moment}
[Abrar Mehmood]

Abrar

Posts : 10
Join date : 2010-11-09

Back to top Go down

View previous topic View next topic Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum