ISSUE IN TIRMIDHI
2 posters
Page 1 of 1
ISSUE IN TIRMIDHI
At the end of the chapter of[Ma ja'aa menur rukhsate fe thalik], Imam Tirmidhi has mentioned this hadeeth is Hasan Sahih.
The question that I would like to pose to my repected brothers is that what does Imam Tirmidhi mean by Hasan Sahih?
The question that I would like to pose to my repected brothers is that what does Imam Tirmidhi mean by Hasan Sahih?
Last edited by Abrar on Sat Dec 18, 2010 11:19 pm; edited 1 time in total
Abrar- Posts : 10
Join date : 2010-11-09
AN ANSWER TO - HASAN SAHIH
Before the chapter of باب النهى عن البول قائما I had previously posed the question of what HASAN SAHIH means.The fact of the matter is that many scholars have tried to explain it,having faced many difficulties,stating different ideas and explanations.
The terminology of Imam Tirmidhi still remains a problem for many scholars till today but Sheikh Mohammed Akram Nadwi has come up with possibly the best solution as yet taking the idea of Ibn Salahs theory from his book [ Muqaddama of Ibn Salah ]. His explanation of HASAN SAHIH is as follows:-
1- حسن
2- صحيح
3- صحيح لغيره
4- حسن غريب
5- حسن
Ibn Salah has used the number 1 as a general term and number 2,3,4,5 as it's components to explain the subject of Hasan.
We firstly have the subject title of Hasan which is a separate category,it also explains the quality of the narrators of the ahadeeth used by the respective scholars.
The first part of Hasan is Sahih,these are those narrators who have a good ضبط and all of the qualities that are required for them to be regarded highly by the muhadditheen.
The second part is Sahih Lighairihee,these are those narrators who don't have the required qualities but have the support of the other narrators which then strengthens their narrations.
The third part is Hasan Gharib,these are those narrators that don't have the required qualities nor the supports but are single in their narrations.
The fourth part is Hasan,these are those narrators that are Dhaeef but are raised to the status of Hasan because they have supports from else where.
In conclusion although the Sheikh has preferred this version but he feels that there is no definite answer to the terminology of Imam Tirmidhi,allah knows the best.
[Abrar Mehmood]
The terminology of Imam Tirmidhi still remains a problem for many scholars till today but Sheikh Mohammed Akram Nadwi has come up with possibly the best solution as yet taking the idea of Ibn Salahs theory from his book [ Muqaddama of Ibn Salah ]. His explanation of HASAN SAHIH is as follows:-
1- حسن
2- صحيح
3- صحيح لغيره
4- حسن غريب
5- حسن
Ibn Salah has used the number 1 as a general term and number 2,3,4,5 as it's components to explain the subject of Hasan.
We firstly have the subject title of Hasan which is a separate category,it also explains the quality of the narrators of the ahadeeth used by the respective scholars.
The first part of Hasan is Sahih,these are those narrators who have a good ضبط and all of the qualities that are required for them to be regarded highly by the muhadditheen.
The second part is Sahih Lighairihee,these are those narrators who don't have the required qualities but have the support of the other narrators which then strengthens their narrations.
The third part is Hasan Gharib,these are those narrators that don't have the required qualities nor the supports but are single in their narrations.
The fourth part is Hasan,these are those narrators that are Dhaeef but are raised to the status of Hasan because they have supports from else where.
In conclusion although the Sheikh has preferred this version but he feels that there is no definite answer to the terminology of Imam Tirmidhi,allah knows the best.
[Abrar Mehmood]
Abrar- Posts : 10
Join date : 2010-11-09
Re: ISSUE IN TIRMIDHI
I am reading a phd thesis done by a student from manchester uni regarding this topic i will get back to you after i have read it insah Allah
zaid- Posts : 1
Join date : 2010-12-18
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum