Shah Waliullah Muhaddith Dehlawi
2 posters
Page 1 of 1
Shah Waliullah Muhaddith Dehlawi
Have any of the shuyookh come across any academic works regarding criticisms of Shah Walilullah Dehlawi?
Ibn Muhammad
IbnMuhammad- Posts : 35
Join date : 2010-08-29
Location : Sheffield
Re: Shah Waliullah Muhaddith Dehlawi
Criticism, as in against right?
If you mean a thorough critique of Shah sb, I'm not aware of any such work. 'Allamah Zahid al-Kawthari and Sheikh Abdur Rashid No'mani have criticised him for certain isolated views.
Their criticism doesn't hold much weight, especially Allama Kawthari's [ra] . I've been made aware that a fuller critique of Allamah Kawthari's [ra] criticism has recently been done by Musa Ferber.
I think the fundamental issue between ‘Allamah al-Kawthari [ra] and Shah Sb. [ra] is that of methodology and approach to fiqh.
Allamah Zahid [ra] has criticised him from his Fiqh Hanafi bias.
You can download Kawthari's Maqalaat from here:
http://www.archive.org/details/makalat.pdf
Also, see here for Kawthari discussion:
http://www.suhaibwebb.com/islam-studies/shaykh-akram-nadwi-on-shah-waliullah-and-the-hujjat-by-andrew-booso/
I hope this helps.
Just to add that some student's of Allamah Kashmiri felt that he wasn't too fond of Shah Sb. I haven't discovered any evidence for this.
If you mean a thorough critique of Shah sb, I'm not aware of any such work. 'Allamah Zahid al-Kawthari and Sheikh Abdur Rashid No'mani have criticised him for certain isolated views.
Their criticism doesn't hold much weight, especially Allama Kawthari's [ra] . I've been made aware that a fuller critique of Allamah Kawthari's [ra] criticism has recently been done by Musa Ferber.
I think the fundamental issue between ‘Allamah al-Kawthari [ra] and Shah Sb. [ra] is that of methodology and approach to fiqh.
Allamah Zahid [ra] has criticised him from his Fiqh Hanafi bias.
You can download Kawthari's Maqalaat from here:
http://www.archive.org/details/makalat.pdf
Also, see here for Kawthari discussion:
http://www.suhaibwebb.com/islam-studies/shaykh-akram-nadwi-on-shah-waliullah-and-the-hujjat-by-andrew-booso/
I hope this helps.
Just to add that some student's of Allamah Kashmiri felt that he wasn't too fond of Shah Sb. I haven't discovered any evidence for this.
khalillaher- Posts : 132
Join date : 2010-08-29
Age : 36
Location : London
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum