Unknown source for a very frequently mentioned hadeeth

I've been thinking for a while, the very common hadeeth that we all say when there is a gathering in a masjid, that when a musalli talks the angel tell him to remain silent and call him habeebullah, if he continues then the angels once again remind him to remain silent and call him khalilullah (I think) and lastly if he continues talking then the angels call him 'aduwwullah, where is the original source form this (shall i say) hadeeth?

If I am in the dark please let me know, but most importantly if anyone can provide a mu'tabar hawaalah (reliable source) I would be most greatful.
Jazaakumullah

Faqat al-Aan
al-'abd
30-1--2010

Afwaan, I didn’t get the time to do a full research on the Hadith you’ve mentioned. As far as I know it's (fabricated). Check al Mawdoa'at lil Qari. Below are the wordings they mentioned..



وحديث : ' إذا دخل الرجل المسجد فتكلم ، قال له الملك : اسكت يا ولي الله ، فإن تكلم ثانية قال له اسكت يا حبيب الله ، فإن تكلم قال له : اسكت يا عدو الله ' وهو حديث مكذوب موضوع مفترى .

(لا أدري من قال هذا، لكن فيما يبدو لي أنه كان محققا للحديث)

So unless a sanad is found, it's best to avoid narrating.

I can safely say that it isn't in Kanz al-Ummal. Some people seem to think that since Kanz is so jami', every hadith must be in there, so if we don't have a reference, just say it's in Kanz!!!(Typical of us)

I think it is mentioned in Fazail Sadaqat?????

Please remember me in your dua's
Khalil Ibn Ilyas Laher
East Ham, London

Jazaakallah sheikh, if your answer is correct then it is worth pondering over that this is being narrated so frequently in countless gatherings.

al-'abd

I recently came accross a display of this (hadith) on the wall of a masjid. The source mentioned below was:

Fataawa Raheemiyyah Vol2 Pg161 (I dont know which print)

But I dont have the actual Fataawa Raheemiyyah so I cannot verify whether or not this is correct.

Nevertheless a hadith should be qouted from the exegesis of hadith and not Fataawa.

Can anyone verify?

al-'Abd

Someone told me the hawala of this via F.Rahimiya is in Kitaab al-Madkhal 2/55.
Anyone know what kitaab this is?!